Supplemental essays have always helped admissions officers understand the person behind the application. But in the age of AI, that job has become much harder.
Today, almost anyone can produce a polished essay. For students, that means the bar has changed. The challenge isn't simply writing well—it's knowing how to write a memorable college essay that gives admissions officers a reason to remember you.
A Tale of Two Essays: Why Your Human Perspective Matters
Imagine two students applying to engineering programs.
The first asks AI to answer the supplemental essay prompt, Why do you want to study engineering?
Within seconds, it produces a polished response about problem-solving, innovation, collaboration, and a lifelong passion for STEM. It's well written. It's articulate. It could also describe hundreds of other applicants.
The second student, Maya, starts in the same place—but doesn't stop there.
Instead of asking AI to tell her why she wants to study engineering, she thinks about where that interest began.
She remembers spending Saturday mornings in her grandfather's basement while he repaired old radios. It wasn't the radios that fascinated her. It was the way her grandfather approached a problem. Before replacing a single part, he'd spend time asking questions, testing assumptions, and figuring out why something had stopped working. Years later, while leading a robotics project, she caught herself using the same approach. That’s when she realized engineering had evolved from a favorite subject into her fundamental way of thinking.
Admissions officers don't remember essay’s like Maya's because they are more polished. They remember them because they tell a unique human story.
What AI Does Well—and Where It Falls Short
AI is an excellent writing assistant. It can help students organize ideas, improve clarity, tighten sentences, and catch grammatical errors. What it can't do is replace lived experience.
It doesn't know the conversation that changed your perspective, the teacher who challenged your assumptions, or the small moment that sparked a lasting interest. It can generate reflection, but it can't create it. That's why essays built entirely on AI often feel surprisingly similar. They may be well written, but they rarely leave a lasting impression.
Tips for Writing a Memorable Essay
Ground your essay in a real moment.
Instead of beginning with a broad statement—"I've always loved science"—begin with a specific experience. A conversation. A setback. A question you couldn't stop thinking about. Real moments immediately make an essay feel authentic because they're rooted in something only you experienced.
Show how you think.
Admissions officers aren't just interested in what you've done. They want to understand how you process challenges, make decisions, and grow from experience. Don't stop at describing an event. Explain what changed your perspective or what questions you're still exploring. That's the kind of insight that can’t be manufactured by a chatbot.
Use AI as an editor, not an author.
There's nothing wrong with using AI to improve sentence flow, eliminate repetition, or identify awkward phrasing. But the ideas, stories, and reflections should come from you. Think of AI as someone proofreading your work—not someone living your life.
The Key to Writing an Essay Colleges Will Remember
Before you submit your essay, ask yourself one question: Could someone else have written this? If the answer is yes, keep digging.
In a world where almost anyone can generate a polished essay, authenticity has become a competitive advantage. What makes an essay memorable isn't perfect writing. It's a perspective, a way of thinking, and a story that could only belong to one student.
